Seafood restaurants

The Original Fish of Stroh

4.0 209 reviews 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM 4230 S 1175 E, LaGrange, IN 46761, United States

Discover this place

The Original Fish of Stroh is a celebrated seafood restaurant nestled in LaGrange, Indiana. From the very first bite, it's clear why patrons, like Ana Bacon, describe it as “a classic gem.” The menu highlights impeccable fish dishes that frequently steal the spotlight, with many recommending the all-you-can-eat option, which is both abundant and budget-friendly at under $45 for two.

Customer experiences overwhelmingly emphasize the exceptional service alongside the delightful culinary offerings. Grandma Bower, a loyal visitor for two decades, couldn’t praise the food enough, while others echoed similar sentiments about the welcoming wait staff and the chef, rumored to be the owner. This familial approach adds a warm touch to your dining experience, fostering a sense of community.

Signature dishes paired with a vibrant salad bar create a dining experience that not only satisfies hunger but also brings back cherished memories of home-cooked meals. Lou Anne, a standout, has been highlighted for her outstanding service and cocktail skills, drawing visitors back for her personal touch. With an inviting atmosphere and a menu that delights the senses, The Original Fish of Stroh is a must-visit for seafood lovers—a place where every meal feels like a celebration.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with The Original Fish of Stroh before visiting.

Reviews for The Original Fish of Stroh

4.0

209 reviews

100%

36%

20%

13%

19%

Review highlights

Based on 209 reviews

The Original Fish of Stroh is consistently praised for its classic, timeless appeal and high-quality seafood offerings. Customers frequently highlight the restaurant’s friendly and attentive service, often noting a personal touch from the staff and ownership. The food is widely described as phenomenal, particularly the fish, which many consider the best in the area. Patrons appreciate the reasonable pricing, especially the value found in options like all-you-can-eat fish meals paired with traditional sides such as baked potatoes and salad bars. The atmosphere evokes a sense of nostalgia and local charm, attracting both longtime residents and new visitors. Additionally, the establishment offers unique touches like vintage items for sale, contributing to its distinctive character. Overall, the brand maintains a strong reputation for combining excellent food, welcoming service, and a warm, inviting environment.

Ana Bacon

Jul 03, 2025

Nothing like the Original Fish of Stroh....a classic gem, just LOVE everything about it! Friendly wait staff, I think the owner is the Chef...best fish ever!

Grandma Bower

Jun 20, 2025

Oh,where to begin? This was the first time, since I grew up in LaGrange, which was about 20 years, that I've been there. Same place, same PHENOMENAL food. Get the all-you-can-eat,you get baked potato,all you can eat fish and salad bar and drink for two people is under 45! The waitress was great as well. Go... you have to now. What are you waiting for goodbye! You will thank me for the tip.

Chris Doehrman

Jun 11, 2025

At South Milford. Food was GREAT. Service was Great an Good prices.

Dorene Trammel

May 29, 2025

Lou Anne is amazing. The food was great amd I would make the trip again just like I did this evening! The cocktail was amazing girl! Thank you!!

Terrie A

May 21, 2025

Also bought a cool vintage coffee pot.

Jim Zix

May 16, 2025

Oh my! We loved Fish of Stroh when our daughters were very small, 25 years ago. The Fort Wayne locations are long-gone, but this location continues on with the original recipes and some new delights. We loved it!

Bill Glover

May 03, 2025

Very cool place. Great food and great service.

Melanie Slack

Apr 03, 2025

Nice little hole in the wall! We got the fish and fries lunch special and coleslaw! Batter on fish was yummy, fish was juicy and flaky! Everything was delicious! Cole slaw is the bomb! Great prices and our waitress was very nice!